We overpaid an employee by mistake: can we take it back from their pay?

What does the law say about taking money back?
Acas sets out the general rule from the Employment Rights Act 1996 in its guide to deductions from pay and wages. An employer can only make a deduction from someone's wages in a short list of cases, and one of them is where the employer overpaid someone by mistake. GOV.UK's guide for employees on deductions from pay lists the same exception as an earlier overpayment of wages or expenses.
The section of the Act that carves out overpayments applies in England, Wales and Scotland. Employers in Northern Ireland should check the rules and advice services that apply there.
So the law does not stop the deduction in most cases. Acas's page on handling overpayments puts it plainly: in most circumstances an employer has the right to claim back money it has overpaid, and it should contact the worker as soon as it is aware of the mistake.
Can we just take it from the next pay?
Having the right does not mean using it without warning. Acas says an employer should not deduct money from someone's wages without letting them know. The employer should talk to the worker first and agree how the money will be paid back.
How that conversation goes depends on the size of the mistake.
| Situation | What Acas suggests |
|---|---|
| A simple overpayment made recently | Tell the worker it will come off their next wages, or agree another way such as a bank transfer |
| A large amount, or one built up over a long period | Be flexible and fair, and agree a repayment plan |
| No repayment plan can be agreed | Acas tells the worker they can contact its helpline to discuss their options |
| The person has already left | Contact them and explain why money is owed and how much |
| A former worker refuses to repay | A court claim may be possible |
Acas also asks employers to consider the worker's wellbeing, because being asked to pay money back can be stressful.
What happens if the deduction comes as a surprise?
Acas's page on making deductions adds a timing point: it says that before making deductions that a worker does not expect, an employer should notify the worker as soon as possible. For the worker's side, GOV.UK tells employees who have not been paid in full to speak to their employer first. If that does not work, it points them to Acas, Citizens Advice or a trade union representative, and says they have the right to go to an Employment Tribunal.
The payslip matters too. Acas says deductions must be clearly stated in a worker's payslip, so a recovery should show on the payslip as its own deduction.
On the minimum wage, GOV.UK says a deduction cannot normally reduce pay below the National Minimum Wage, and lists repayment of an accidental overpayment of wages as an exception. That covers the minimum wage rule. It does not settle what is fair for the person repaying it.
What does payroll need to record?
HMRC's guide to fixing problems with running payroll covers how a mistake with pay or deductions is reported. It says you can correct it by updating the year to date figures in your next regular Full Payment Submission, or by sending an additional one before the next regular submission is due. The same guide sets out separate steps for National Insurance and student loan mistakes from earlier tax years. The routes are set out in more detail in our post on how payroll corrections get reported to HMRC.
Alongside that, keep a note of what was agreed with the worker: the amount, how it will be recovered, over how many pay periods, and when the conversation took place. Payroll processes the recovery on that instruction, so it helps to have that instruction clear and on record.
When is this not the answer?
Recovering the money straight from the next pay is not always the right route. Where the sum is large or built up over a long period, Acas says to be flexible and fair and to agree a repayment plan. It tells workers they can contact its helpline where a repayment plan cannot be agreed, or where the worker believed they were being paid the correct amount and will struggle to pay the money back.
If you would like to talk through how recoveries are handled on your own payroll, get in touch with Alpine.
This is general information, not advice on your own position.
Reviewed against official sources, November 2026.
Questions we hear
Does the worker have to agree in writing before we deduct an overpayment?
In Acas's list, an overpayment made by mistake is its own ground for a deduction, separate from a deduction the worker agreed to in writing. Acas still says the employer should talk to the worker first and agree how the money will be paid back.
Can recovering an overpayment take someone's pay below the National Minimum Wage?
GOV.UK lists repayment of an accidental overpayment of wages among the deductions that can do this. That answers the minimum wage question, not what is fair for the person repaying it.
What if the employee has already left?
Acas says the employer should contact them and explain why money is owed and how much. If the former worker refuses to pay it back, the employer might be able to make a court claim.
Do we need to tell HMRC?
If the overpaid pay was reported in a Full Payment Submission, it is corrected in the same way as other pay mistakes. HMRC's payroll errors guide says you can correct a mistake with pay or deductions by updating the year to date figures in your next regular Full Payment Submission, or by sending an additional one before it is due.
Sources
Talk to Alpine
If you have a question about your own payroll, we would be pleased to hear from you.
Get in touch

