The payroll risk of one person knowing everything

Alpine Payroll Marketing Team · 30 June 2026 · 2 min read

A meeting room with a white table, chairs and a laptop.
Photo: cottonbro studio on Pexels

HMRC has described the problem

One line in HMRC's April Employer Bulletin puts it well. Writing about employee share scheme returns, due by 6 July 2026 for the 2025 to 2026 tax year, HMRC says that every year many customers miss the deadline because they cannot log in, adding that this is "often because the only person who could log in to file the return is not available or has left the company".

HMRC's suggestion there is a backup administrator on the Government Gateway account, so that critical functions can still be carried out. That article is about share schemes, but the same thinking is easy to apply to payroll.

Payroll runs to fixed dates

Payroll runs to fixed dates whoever is in the office. HMRC's guide to running payroll sets out the regular cycle:

When What is due
On or before each payday Full Payment Submission
By the 19th of the next tax month Employer Payment Summary, for any claims
By the 22nd of the next tax month Payment to HMRC, or the 19th by post

Around those sit the dates that come once a year, which are the easiest to carry in one person's head. HMRC's February bulletin gives two of them: P60s to employees by 31 May, and P11D reporting by 6 July.

Spreading the knowledge

None of this needs new systems. Start with a few practical steps, which are our own suggestions.

Find out who can log in to each HMRC account and the payroll software, and add a second person where you can. Put the year's dates in a shared calendar. Ask for a short written note of how a pay run actually happens here: where the hours come from, who approves what, and which staff have something unusual about their pay.

Then try it. Let someone else follow the note during a live pay period, with the usual person beside them. The gaps show up quickly, and they are far easier to fill while that person is still there to help.

Records matter here too. HMRC's guide to keeping records expects you to hold details of pay, deductions, reports and payments to HMRC, along with leave and sickness absences. These should be somewhere the business can reach, rather than in one person's inbox.

Where outsourcing fits

Some employers decide that a team is a better answer than a deputy, and hand the running of payroll to an outside provider. That spreads the work across more people, though it brings its own questions about what you supply and who you speak to. Where payroll stays on your own PAYE scheme, your legal position does not move with the work, so the records and the oversight still need an owner inside your business.

Either route can work, as long as more than one person can keep your payroll going. To compare notes on your own set up, give Alpine a call.

This is general information, not advice on your own position.

Reviewed against official sources, November 2026.

Sources

Alpine Payroll Marketing TeamAlpine Payroll Limited

Payroll news and guidance from the marketing team at Alpine Payroll Limited.

Talk to Alpine

If you have a question about your own payroll, we would be pleased to hear from you.

Get in touch