Payroll IDs: the small RTI field HMRC has warned about

It says: "Employers continue to create duplicate employments when a payroll ID is changed but the payroll ID change indicator is not used." HMRC's systems then treat the new ID as a new job.
The errors HMRC lists
| What happens | What HMRC says follows | What HMRC asks you to do |
|---|---|---|
| An ID changes with no indicator, or the old ID is left out | Duplicate employment, incorrect year to date information | Tick the indicator and give both the old and new IDs |
| A start date or starter declaration is sent instead of the indicator | A second employment record for the same employee | Use the indicator instead |
| A genuine new employment has no start date | Separate employments can merge | Enter a start date for all new employees, and leave it blank for continuing ones |
| An ID is reused for a different employee | Split data, details on the wrong record, disputed charges | Use a unique ID for each employee, and avoid reusing those of former employees |
The same section also warns about taxable pay. Sending nil in the period field while the year to date field is filled in can result in merged or incorrect records, so HMRC asks for the correct figure for each period, with year to date totals that follow logically from it.
The rules behind the field
HMRC's FPS guidance says the ID must be unique. It says to use a different one if you take someone back on, or if an employee has more than one job in the same PAYE scheme. "If you reuse a previous payroll ID you'll create a duplicate record and report payroll incorrectly".
The indicator has its own limits. It should be set only when reporting a change of ID, with both IDs entered and without the original start date. It should not be set for someone who has come back in the same tax year under a different ID.
When to look harder
The moments to check are the ones where IDs can change without anyone deciding to change them. HMRC singles out payroll systems that generate new IDs automatically, and asks employers to use the indicator in that case.
So watch for a software update, a new payroll system, a change of payroll provider or a tidy up of staff numbers. In each of those, find out before the first submission whether IDs will carry over unchanged. If they will not, make sure the old and new IDs go in together.
A former member of staff coming back is the other moment. A fresh ID is correct there, even though reusing the old one can feel tidier.
If your bill looks wrong
The guide to fixing payroll problems says mistakes with starters and leavers can produce an incorrect bill and duplicate records, and that both are usually corrected automatically. If your PAYE bill is still wrong by the 12th of the next tax month, you can ask HMRC for help.
If a change of system is coming up, Alpine can talk it through with you.
This is general information, not advice on your own position.
Reviewed against official sources, November 2026.
Sources
Talk to Alpine
If you have a question about your own payroll, we would be pleased to hear from you.
Get in touch

