Net pay or relief at source: the mix up HMRC corrected in June

The two methods
| Net pay arrangement | Relief at source | |
|---|---|---|
| When the deduction is made | Before PAYE is operated | After Income Tax has been charged |
| How tax relief is given | Automatically, at the employee's marginal rate | The provider claims the basic rate from HMRC and adds it to the pot |
| Higher rate relief | No separate claim needed | The employee claims it from HMRC |
| FPS field | Employee pension contributions paid under a net pay arrangement | Employee pension contributions not paid under a net pay arrangement |
HMRC's example of relief at source is a relievable contribution of £100. The employee pays £80 through a deduction from pay, and the provider claims the other £20 from HMRC.
Where the mistake happens
HMRC says some employers report contributions in the wrong field, possibly because of the names given to each method. HMRC's example is relief at source contributions reported in the net pay field. Tax relief is then given twice: once through payroll, and again through the provider and HMRC.
HMRC describes the excess relief as "an employer payroll failure", with the employer liable for the tax under deducted and not paid over. Reporting net pay contributions in the other field is also an error, HMRC says.
Set when the scheme is registered
The method belongs to the scheme. HMRC says an individual cannot choose it, and that relief at source has been the default for all new registered pension schemes since April 2006. An employer can elect to use a net pay arrangement at the start of a new scheme if it meets certain conditions, but once a scheme is registered, the form of relief is set.
What to do now
Ask your pension provider how your scheme is registered. Then compare that with how your payroll reports contributions on the FPS. Those are the checks HMRC asks uncertain employers to make.
If they do not match, HMRC says to correct your payroll immediately. Errors from previous periods go through the HMRC digital disclosure facility, or through your Customer Compliance Manager if you are a large business with one.
If you have more than one scheme, check each one, since the answer may not be the same across them.
Who should raise this
If someone else runs your payroll, this is a fair question to ask them.
If pension data is a question for your business, Alpine can talk it through with you.
This is general information, not advice on your own position.
Reviewed against official sources, November 2026.
Sources
Talk to Alpine
If you have a question about your own payroll, we would be pleased to hear from you.
Get in touch

